Carter Hart’s suspension is over. He’s officially allowed back into the NHL, and he appears set to start in the first game he’s eligible, tomorrow night vs. Chicago.
In an effort to cover this situation equitably, from the moment it became clear the Golden Knights were the destination for Hart, I dug in. I read the 91-page verdict. I reviewed news stories from before, during, and after the trial. I examined the petition against the signing. I read as many related social media posts as I could stomach. If someone wrote, said, or otherwise conveyed something about the trial, I’ve probably consumed it.
So far, we’ve heard from Hart, many of his new teammates, and the head coach. The organization released a statement regarding his addition, and the league issued reasons for his reinstatement following the mandated suspension. He spoke again today, mostly about his experiences playing in Henderson.
Moving forward, we will cover his play on the ice, his involvement in the community, his interaction with teammates, fan reaction, both positive and negative, and if the general manager ever speaks on the topic at a press conference, his thoughts as well.
Before all of this happens, though, I want to present the thoughts of another source I believe adds an immense amount of knowledge and weight to this trial and the broader issues surrounding high-profile sexual assault cases.
Over the summer, top Canadian indie podcast Canadian True Crime produced a five-part series dissecting the Hockey Canada trial in detail, opening my eyes to angles on this I never could have even fathomed.
Host Kristi Lee connected me to two sexual assault survivors, Kelly Favro and Jessica Baker, who were consulted extensively for the series and are hockey fans themselves. Baker testified against high-profile musician and former Canadian Idol finalist Jacob Hoggard in 2022. Hoggard happened to be represented by the same defense attorney as Carter Hart. He was found guilty and sentenced to five years in prison.
As “J.B.” in the Jacob Hoggard case, I went through years of court proceedings, public testimony, delays, appeals, and the public reaction that comes with all of it. That experience changed how I understand these situations. -Jessica Baker
She acknowledged that topics like this can be uncomfortable for hockey fans.
Most people follow the sport to enjoy it, not to get pulled into legal or ethical debates. I’m not here to shame anyone for that -Baker
I asked Baker and Favro what they would most want people to know about the Hockey Canada case and other sexual assault trials. In coordination with podcaster Kristi Lee, they shared six points for “fans who want context without feeling attacked.”
1) An acquittal is only a legal conclusion, not a moral one.
In sexual assault cases, a not-guilty verdict is often misunderstood as proof the accused is innocent, the victim lied, or that no harm occurred. In reality, the bar for conviction is extremely high. The prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, which is often difficult in sexual assault cases where the body is the crime scene.
Favro notes that the accused has strong legal protections, including the right to silence and full representation, while the victim appears only as a prosecution witness with none of those rights.
The result is that her credibility is scrutinized under a microscope while the accused can sit silently, shielded by legal protections. -Kelly Favro
A not-guilty verdict often reflects the limitations of a justice system that wasn’t built to handle the complexities of sexual violence, power dynamics, or the science behind the impact of trauma.
This is why many trials devolve into accusations using outdated rape myths about how a “real victim” should behave. This is why we often see women being unfairly portrayed as liars, hysterics or vengeful manipulators. -Favro
2) The text message victim-complainant E.M. sent to Michael McLeod the day after the hotel room incident deserves much more attention:
“I was ok with going home with you, it was everyone else afterwards that I wasn’t expecting.”
Favro says the judge, Justice Maria Carrocia, did not acknowledge the weight of this message, the dismissive nature of McLeod’s response, or the complete lack of evidence that E.M. ever requested, anticipated, or even wanted additional players to enter the hotel room that night.
This should have been the line that everyone should have paused a very long time on. People need to understand that E.M. consented to sex with Michael McLeod only. Everything that happened after that was without her knowledge or consent. -Favro
3) The criminal trial is over, but the conversation around “disturbing and unacceptable behaviour” isn’t.
In the NHL statement, Gary Bettman said that the allegations in this case, even if not determined to have been criminal, were very disturbing and the behaviour at issue was unacceptable.
Baker says this isn’t about asking fans to choose sides, because it’s not a simple “he’s completely cleared” or “he’s entirely guilty” situation.
You can support your team and still understand why some people feel uneasy, and why major institutions have recognized the conduct fell below acceptable standards. Those things can coexist. Acknowledging harm doesn’t require turning your back on the sport. -Baker
4. Carter Hart insists he has grown, but real change starts with acknowledging harm and taking accountability. He hasn’t ever done that.
At his recent press conference, Carter Hart said he had learned from the experience and was ready to show his true character. But Kristi Lee notes that this doesn’t match the testimony he gave at the trial just a few months earlier.
Hart testified when he entered that hotel room he wanted to ensure everything was fully consensual and that he would have left if anyone was disrespectful to E.M. Yet even in his own version of events, he took no actual steps to ensure consent — from his excitement at a 2 AM invite to have sex with a woman he didn’t know, to the red flags he ignored that she wasn’t consenting, to his decision to text another player to join without checking with her. -Lee, host of Canadian True Crime
Lee argues that if Hart wants the public to believe he has truly changed and learned something meaningful, he needs to show it through his actions.
Justice doesn’t end with a verdict. He could step forward as a role model and use his public platform to raise awareness and prevent future harm. He could say, ‘I was found not criminally guilty, but that night wasn’t right. We all should have done better, and here’s what I’ve learned.’ -Lee, host of Canadian True Crime
Until he offers real accountability instead of vague statements about growth, Lee says mixed public reactions are inevitable.
5) The trial revealed a serious lack of public awareness around real consent and what it looks like.
We received many questions from men asking how the hockey players were supposed to know E.M.’s behaviour was consistent with submission, compliance and appeasement, not actual consent. It starts with genuine care for the other person’s comfort and agency, instead of focusing on personal satisfaction. -Lee, host of Canadian True Crime
Here are some guidelines she shared:
- Real consent is enthusiastic, ongoing, specific, and freely given.
- Consent to one act or person doesn’t cover another act or person. Everyone needs their own clear, verbal, enthusiastic yes for every act, which often means asking clear questions before anything happens: “Are you sure you want this?” “What about now?” “Are you okay with someone else joining?”
- There is no such thing as advance or retroactive consent, and it can be withdrawn at any time. This is why a “consent” video doesn’t prove it.
- When consent is not present, there will be obvious red flags, including hesitation, silence, stiffness, crying, nervous laughter, over-performing, or signs of heavy drinking. E.M. displayed many of these red flags.
- When there is a clear power imbalance, the responsibility falls on those with power or status to go above and beyond to make sure consent is real, not coerced, and that the person feels free and safe to say no if they want to.
6) What’s missing from the public conversation: survivors of sexual assault don’t get to move on in the same way that the accused does. They live with this forever.
Survivors rebuild themselves with limited support, often paying out of pocket for therapy, medication, and the basic tools that help them get through a day without slipping back into memories they never asked for.
They often have publication bans put on their identities without their knowledge or consent, which is why in Canada, they are often referred to by their initials. The process is supposed to protect the survivor’s identity, but publication bans can also result in the survivor being penalized for identifying themselves or speaking, correcting misinformation, or filling in gaps.
There may be a tendency to perceive Carter Hart’s future success potentially as a loss for victims and survivors, but Favro and Baker push back on that.
Our well-being is not tied to anyone’s career success or failure. -Baker
Favro says survivors never fully heal from the assault, and they never forget what the court process added to that.
Understanding that truth helps everyone see the full picture, not just the part that shows up in a courtroom or on the ice. -Favro
The full verdict from the trial can be found here. Danny Webster of the Las Vegas Review-Journal recently published a comprehensive timeline of events, including further comments from GM Kelly McCrimmon. Hart’s first meeting with the press in Las Vegas is here. Here are the statements from the Golden Knights and the NHL. All episodes of the Canadian True Crime podcast on the Hockey Canada Trial, as well as source material used for the series, are available here.


Concerned fan
I had really hoped that the nights would not pick him up. It is clear that he is not showing any remorse nor any growth since the trial and your post just outline that. I’ve been a golden Knights fan since the first preview and now I’m rethinking how I feel about the team and management
knights fan in minny
See ya
Connie West
Found “not guilty”. Accept it, move on. This shouldn’t be here for your moral crusade. Let it go.
Peter A Ricci
Spot on, “not guilty”. If someone has issues with Canada’s criminal justice system, move to Canada and seek changes. Stop disrespecting our northern neighbor.
KWWA
If it were your daughter, would you say the same?
LV
If it were your son, would you say the same ?
Richie-Rich
My daughter wouldn’t leave her boyfriend to go off and fuck a hockey player who she didn’t even know. We had a name for girls like this back in my day. To be nice, one of the labels for her would be “easy”. Her father should go look in the mirror and ask himself where he went wrong in parenting. She should never have put herself into that situation in the first place, period. She’s not innocent, and neither are any of the other “men” involved. I use the term “men” extremely liberally. Whore mongers would be a better description.
Nikki
My daughter wouldn’t be in a bar alone, drinking with a bunch of men she doesn’t know, and then leave to a hotel room to have sex. Problem avoided.
Wendy
I can see their side but to say he came to have sex with a woman he didnt know when she had sex with his teammate that she didn’t know either. Why should he be held to that standard but she wasn’t?
Woxy
Are we all blind to the fact that the President was CONVICTED of sexual assault! Start your moral judgement and have him removed from office!
David Kollar
Really that’s the question you wanna ask? Fine then let’s say they’re both wrong then you need to start asking the tough questions doesn’t that mean he’s in a position of power to take advantage of her sure her judgment was bad to say the least, but he still clearly wrong
hdbiker7851
Just a simple quick question – how do you know how he feels or doesn’t feel. Tell me you have never done something you are not happy about and go around telling anyone who will listen how you feel. He is in a difficult position and regardless how he responded he would be open to criticism. Your major concern as well as everyone else should be is whether or not he can help your hockey team. There is an old axiom – if you can’t say something good about a person say nothing at all – there is something to consider about that line of reasoning. Hopefully he is the answer to the Knights goalie situation which isn’t in the best of shape.
Emmanuel
If he was your kids/grandkids babysitter instead of a goalie would you both have the same point of view?
Squid
“Your major concern should be whether or not he can help your hockey team—NOT whether or not he sexually assaulted someone which obviously doesn’t matter at all compared to winning a hockey game.”
Are you okay
Rydia
No kidding – lot of perfect people in these comments apparently.
Was what Carter Hart did stupid? Yes.
Was it criminal? No.
Let he who is without sin cast the first stone.
KWWA
I’m pretty sure that test I cheated on in the 3rd grade isn’t the same as raping someone, but sure, go on with the false equivalence.
Christians really are the worst advertisements for Christianity.
Matt
But it’s fair of you to take one person’s stupid comment and blanket-accuse ALL Christians? That makes you sound just as ignorant. Just an observation. I’m sorry if you stumbled into a church one day and saw a hypocrite, but that gives you no right to lump all Christians into the same guilt. Especially while I’m sure you go around saying it’s not right to hate all Arabs simply because of 9/11, and you’d be absolutely right to say so. I’m not even Christian, but I’m so sick of it being perfectly acceptable in society to hate and constantly attack Christian’s while all other religions get a free pass. I’m sorry to be the one to tell you, but you sound really “Christian” right now.
Susan
Absolutely agree with your statement
not happy fan
He should have apologized and said it was wrong and he should have stopped it men will never understand what women go through after this. Maybe you did the same at some point?? Put yourself in there shoes being raped is unimaginable and this is why most women don’t report it. It’s a sad world we live in today
stuuuuuuuuuuuuu
Yes, I absolutely agree. What he did was wrong in ways most people will never understand. He can’t take back his actions, but apologizing and taking accountability is the bare minimum.
Rocco
How do you feel now?
Herby
Let’s focus on hockey.
Dean
I love my sports but some things are more important than hockey. This man should never play in the NHL ever again and Im extremely disappointed that he’s playing for VGK.
Nikki
I agree. Enjoying a sport doesn’t make it immune from being talked about in real-world conversations. We can love hockey and still talk about the harm that’s connected to it. The actions of the people involved have serious implications and pretending it doesn’t matter does a disservice to everyone.
I appreciate Ken Boehlke for writing this article. It’s not something that’s easy to talk about and people get very aggressive when there is any kind of dissent against the team. And, especially, this topic.
Sad fan
People care more about the sport than the crimes that happen under it. This is not the first rape case there has been many and ANY sports player should get a lifetime ban.
Nikki
HE WAS ACQUITTED. Why does everyone not understand this???? According to the law… you cannot call him a rapist. That makes YOU GUILTY OF SLANDER. What part of the real world do we not get?? Bad choice. Absolutely. She made bad decisions as well.
Integrity
Ditto
TS
Yes, Integrity. Character. Self- restraint are others…like “keep it in.your pants” !!
. Another: ” NO MEANS NO”.
Whether the female was drunk.or impaired, A ” Gang Bang” is still Rape. Unconsenting rape.
This entire affair reeks of ” Boy’s Club Perks”, as in ” she really wants it, or she wouldn’t have been in the situation in the first place”.
Why would Foley, a man of Integrity, even Consider this guy?
As a woman, i find this extremely DISTURBING.
.
Rydia
If you seriously believe that no athlete ever has participated in consensual group sex with one or more willing women, you are in for an extremely rude awakening.
Just because you wouldn’t participate in group sex yourself does not mean it’s rape. There are swingers clubs in multiple cities where women can and do go to participate in this type of activity.
Not to mention that this woman never said no, she was literally demanding sex and berating the men who would not partake. Regret is not rape.
It’s interesting how many of these comments berate the men and then act like she had no agency when the evidence proved SHE was the aggressor.
Sad fan
No he shouldn’t but I guess the NHL doesn’t care who they hurt as long as they are making money
Rick
Acquittal is not the same as Not Guilty.
When referees review a play, there may not be enough evidence to reverse the call, but it basically relying on the camera angles available. Those cameras dont catch everything. Neither do people, jury’s, or judges. How Carter Hart moves forward should be very telling. Perhaps he should donate a portion of his income to help programs that protect women.
Rydia
Acquittal and not guilty are literally the exact same thing.
Carter Hart can spend his money wherever he wants. You don’t care about women or justice. You just want to punish him forever.
The league already punished him. It was punishment enough considering his only mistake was getting involved with a golddigger and exhibiting poor judgement.
EM has just as much of a role in the situation as everyone else did. Stop infantilizing her. She was a grown adult who made her own choices, just as they did.
Natalie
Michelle, your comments show how uneducated you are about this trial. No evidence showed E.M. was the aggressor. The only “evidence” you speak of was the word of the men who showed up in the room. One of whom was completely inconsistent with his words on the stand. If you saw the video evidence, you would’ve seen that she was crying in them. That alone, is true “evidence” of someone who is not an aggressor. It’s fairly clear you don’t have daughters, or any perspective of how a woman would feel in a room full of men. Yes, she made poor decisions that night that she clearly regrets. No, she was not an aggressor. You have every right to take a side here. However spreading misinformation is harmful. Check the data before you throw legal jargon around.
Rydia
Yeah, the woman who was so scared being in a room full of men she went back after she left to retrieve a worthless piece of costume jewelry. She admitted to this. I am so over this type of feminism that assumes we’re all brainless walking vessels with no agency who just have thing happen to us. Stop infantilizing women; it sets us back.
If she had been crying in the video, it would have been all over the news. Given how quickly the subject was dropped, I’m guessing that was another of the many lies she told. So many, in fact, that it took 12 pages for the judge to list them all.
I read the news, followed the trial, and read all 94 pages of the judges decision. Everything I’ve said is detailed in those pages. You, on the other hand, are just repeating the talking points that have been disproven by the evidence and testimony, including EM’s own. The only person who refuses to educate themselves is you.
Jonathan
Natalie, it is clear you didn’t read the judges 91-page verdict linked above.
If you had, you would have seen that there are 9 pages solely dedicated to the inconsistencies and credibility issues surrounding EM’s testimony.
You would have read that she was naked on the floor masturbating in front of five men. That she was berating the men and calling them p****** for NOT having sex her.
You would have read that in her initial claim, the team got her drunk and took advantage of her. Yet video from the bar shows her buy herself 8 drinks and the players bought her 0 drinks.
You would have read that her friend was trying to get her away from the players bc she had a boyfriend, but she continually left her friend to go home with a player.
Maybe read a little before calling people “uneducated”.
Nikki
Amen!!!!!
PJT
His income should be spent on making coaches attend ethics classes so they can better coach his/her team on off ice activities and it’s consequences. His income should be donated to a cause or petition to increase the legal drinking age from 19 to 21 in Ontario. His income should be donated to a cause to reduce masculine toxicity in the locker rooms and handling peer pressure in this sport. Finally his income should be donated to research towards a better helmet to protect the player against concussions from hits and flying pucks. The last thing his income should be donated to is to protect women from going out after 11pm to a bar in order to find a hook up. Both sides need to make better choices.
Rydia
Honestly, all the junior teams could do with far more supervision. I realize these guys were legal adults but most professional teams enforce curfews for this very reason.
My cousins only played junior/college hockey and I’m all about letting kids be independent, but sometimes the lodging situations were the equivalent of “let’s put a man-eating tiger in the baby’s playpen.”
Natalie
Here crying and wiping her face was all over the news? I guess you were following the parts of the documents you wanted to read. Your bias is extremely prevalent.
RWJ II
The man did not play for 22 months. That is a large amount of money lost due to an accusation that ended in a not guilty verdict. As both a Flyers and a VGK fan, CH should be allowed to continue in the crease after scoring his first victory last night in Chicago
MCG
I’d just like to point out that there are so many men in the world whom have never been in this type of situation before and its most likely because they actually cared about the other person’s experience as much as their own.
Rydia
You retraumatized these women for clicks. This renders any moral stance you take null and void.
It’s also notable that you left out most of the facts of the case, most likely because they don’t fit your narrative.
This wasn’t a case of “reasonable doubt” or “not enough evidence to convict”. The judge flat out said there was consent and called EM out as a liar.
Carter Hart is the victim of a false accusation and should be allowed to resume his career without cultures like you stalking him.
Nick
If you believe that case was so cut and dry that we should not still be talking about it then I’ve got a bridge to sell you. The fact that the jury was dismissed multiple times and the Judge made the final verdict is abnormal. So no Hart and the rest aren’t “victims”. They’re the perpetrators.
Nice touch accusing Ken of retraumatizing Baker and Favro when he asked for consent to print their words, as is his moral and journalistic duty. Something Hart and the others never did.
Johnny
Are you familiar with the case? Did you read the evidence? Nearly every claim that EM made was proven to be false. All things point to her being fully complicit, if not the aggressor.
Favs
Favro here.
I wasn’t retraumatized giving this interview. And Hart is not a victim.
Rydia
Good. Can we say the same for the other woman?
I’m sorry that happened to you, but your trauma and feelings about the case do not override the facts, which overwhelmingly indicate EM was the aggressor and tried to retroactively withdraw consent, then refused to take accountability for her actions. False accusers like her to you and other victims a severe disservice.
This case, which never should have gone to trial, has set actual victims back decades and done irreparable harm to the survivors movement. So not only were these men the victims of a false accusation and a show trial, now this will make the public much more skeptical when an accusation surfaces. So, by extent, actual victims have been revictimized by her actions.
And yet people like Ken are circling the wagons around a woman proven to have been lying in court. It’s completely asinine.
Kristi Lee
Kristi Lee from Canadian True Crime here. Please stop spreading misinformation.
Ken reached out to me at the podcast as a first step. Kelly Favro and Jessica Baker willingly submitted written responses to his questions. We founded advocacy group Beyond The Verdict.ca.
Rydia
So you admit this was an advocacy piece that was biased from the get-go. Good to know. Having a condition or being a victim of any type of trauma do not make you a subject matter expert, nor do they give you any moral authority whatsoever.
The trial documents, media articles, and judge’s decision have been publicly available for months now. Everything I said is detailed extensively in them. If you refuse to read or acknowledge them, that’s your problem. Facts you don’t like are not misinformation.
You don’t care about survivors, women, or even justice. You just want to libel and harass exonerated men for the rest of their lives. Your “advocacy” actively harms the people you claim to care about.
Bruce
Should Carter Hart be able to play in the NHL? Ken? I did not read the 91 page verdict or talk to two sexual assault survivors. The only thing I know is that he was found not guilty. Should Carter Hart be allowed to play, Ken?
F*ckHart
No. Clearly you need to read point #1 that literally says “ In sexual assault cases, a not-guilty verdict is often misunderstood as proof the accused is innocent, the victim lied, or that no harm occurred. In reality, the bar for conviction is extremely high. The prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, which is often difficult in sexual assault cases where the body is the crime scene.” aka. Not-guilty doesn’t mean sh*t. So no they can struggle to find a low paying “regular person job” like everyone else♀️ do some research on it and tell me how safe you’d feel leaving your daughter with one of these scumbags.
Magda
Couldn’t agree less.
By your standard everyone accused of sexual assault is 100% guilty regardless of the trial outcome.
The judge flat out didn’t believe the accuser in this instance, neither did I after reading through absolutely everything trial related.
Carter Hart was not guilty of sexual assault, I hope he’s able to resume his life/career.
Pat
Throwing out 2 juries, and the judge unilaterally making the decision herself, is about as sketchy as you can get when it comes to verdicts. They did it, they will never be held accountable. Hockey Canada is too big to be held accountable. I hope the judge enjoys her payoff.
Jonathan
Your floating some crackpot conspiracy theory in which a judge with 20+ years of experience is somehow unable to reach a fair verdict.
You’re claiming she took a “payoff” without any evidence.
If you are capable of reading that many pages consecutively, you should read the attached verdict at the bottom of the article.
Its only 91 pages champ.
Wendy
So I guess we retry him until you get the verdict you want? He went thru the legal process. Is it perfect
.no it isn’t but he went to trial. He now has the right to resume his life and his career.
NAM
What a piece of shit article. Seriously. And this is a home town team site. Wow! I don’t watch sports cause I think everybody playing in it goes to church and is a outstanding person. Truth is I really don’t care what players do outside of the game. That is for them, the law, and god to work out. NFL players have literally murdered people while in the league. All sports have their wife beaters, gambling, rape, murder, assault, theft, robbery, drugs, drugs, drugs. Steroids and performance enhancing drugs have forever tarnished records. I don’t give a shit about any of it. I watch sports because I enjoy sports. You have been sitting on this article waiting to shit on this guy for a long time now. Just waiting for him to get his moment, then BLAM. Super pathetic! As a long time frequenter of this site, I think this is super fucked up.
Integrity
I really hope that a “sports” person never rapes your daughter, sister, mother, aunt, or friend.
NAM
What a weird thing to say.
Holy Cow
This is such a horrible response to this. A truly awful human lives behind those keys. Wow.
TS
Wow. Nam, THAT is what is missing in Sports(. Esp
.PROS): a collective Conscience
.NFL is filled with men with the lack of Conscience
. NBA, even worse. Coaches involved!
Are the immoral or illegal actions of athletes now considered the ” NORM”, and not the exception?? Are we now so used to the abhorrent behavior of entitled athletes, that we just brush it off as ” Boys WILL be Boys”??
NAM
What the fuck are you blabbering about? I don’t care about what ever you are unintelligently writing. You miss the point to my post. I watch sports because I like sports. I don’t watch hockey to care that Eichel’s wife wore a pretty dress to some event. I don’t care that Cassidy’s kid plays some local sport. And I sure as hell don’t care what players do outside of the game, good or bad. That is not to say I am accepting or turning a blind eye to bad actions. It doesn’t affect me. If a player commits a crime, that is for the law to handle. If a player punches a coach/player in practice, that is for the team to handle. If a player, years ago, gets a blow job in a strange he said or she said situation, but that player is neither in trouble with the law or with the league or with the team, I don’t fucking care at all. Put him in. If the law or the league or the team remove him from play, so be it. Bring in the next guy. If CH wasn’t in the league right now I wouldn’t care, next man up. But he is and he is playing for my team and I want him to win and kick ass. If he sucks “at hockey”, then I don’t want him on the team and want someone better.
TS
Nam, Way to be the kind of man that women steer a mile clear of. BRAVO.
RWJII
How do you know that NAM is a male?
USMC
Ok, coming from a woman and also a survivor. Nam is exactly right. You are, for some reason, not comprehending what he is saying. CH deserves to play. He went thru the system and is not guilty. That’s it. If you want to go further into the case as I did, then you can make an informed decision on what you want to believe happened. She consented on video. She lied numerous times. She set back real victims. I do question if there is a difference in Canada vs USA on why she filed a civil case first? To me that’s automatic money hunter not victim. Sorry. You go after criminal charges not money. Once they are criminally convicted go after all the money they ever had or will ever have!
Anyway, best of luck to Vegas. Wish he was still in Philly.
n
incredible conversation. thank you for reaching out and expanding clearly with victims in mind and centered.
Nikki
Some things we shouldn’t stay silent about. Thank you for this article.
Jake
Difficult to treat “fairly.”
There are bad apples among those accusing and those who are accused.
PJT
Ken, fairness requires that we look at the full picture, not just the headlines. We’re talking about a 19-year-old who spent his formative years in an insulated, high-pressure world—locker rooms, buses, rinks—surrounded almost entirely by teammates who functioned like brothers. That environment doesn’t excuse poor judgement, but it does help explain how easily a young athlete can be influenced, especially when alcohol and celebration are involved.
And that’s a crucial point: this was a situation involving multiple young people who were clearly intoxicated. Alcohol lowers inhibitions, impairs judgement, and creates a setting where decisions are made that sober individuals would never consider. It doesn’t absolve responsibility, but it dramatically changes how we understand the dynamics of that night.
Did he make a mistake? Absolutely. Should he have shown better judgement? No question. And it’s hard to imagine that he isn’t deeply regretful of where this has led. The statement you criticized was crafted by his lawyer, not by him personally—yet you concluded it showed a lack of remorse, when in reality it simply reflects the cautious nature of legal advice.
Is Carter Hart flawed? Yes—because he is human. The real question is whether his behavior that night stemmed from malice or from immaturity, impaired judgement, and a powerful sense of loyalty to teammates in a heavily intoxicated environment. Those distinctions matter when assessing intent and responsibility.
Regarding the complainant, it’s not about assigning blame to her, but it is reasonable to acknowledge the context: multiple individuals were intoxicated, the incident was not reported for several years, and the lawsuit ultimately targeted the league rather than the individuals involved. Those factors don’t negate her experience, but they do raise legitimate questions about the broader circumstances and motivations surrounding the legal action.
ennEll
Wrong. The complaint was filed with Hickey Canada by EM’s mothers boyfriend within hours of the assaults.
The court matter occurred because others became aware of the slush fund and made inquiries into it, thereby finding out about EM and the terrible initial investigation.
It’s laid out in We Breed Lions by one of the journalists.
Paul
I am conflicted somewhat. Let’s say CH was found guilty, went to prison. His cellmate and he agreed to having sex, but others were invited into the cell and they also had sex. How would CH feel about that upon his release? Reflection of good times or embarrassment, humiliation, and regret.
PJT
For god sakes it was a 60 second blow job and he did asked her for consent and she performed the act on him. It wasn’t forced. The female judge found them not guilty while finding the victim’s testimony to be unreliable. Let’s stick to hockey guys. If CH sucks and we lose to Bedard, he will no doubt hear more boo birds than any other stadium. I personally would wish him good luck going back to Henderson. But let’s just give him a chance and see what he has to show for us. Afterall how can we truly be a team of misfits if don’t give second chances.
George T
This is the way
randomton
I was thinking similarly.
For all the men in the replies who are quick to jump in and defend Hart, imagine this and don’t weasel out:
You’re in the middle of sex with your new girlfriend. All of a sudden, you notice a couple other men at the door to the bedroom, they’re huge and clearly expecting sex with you when she’s done.
How do you feel? What if it turned out your girlfriend invited them without ever discussing it with you? What if they’re way bigger than you are, not wanting to take no for an answer, and you’re super drunk? How you feel now? How about in the morning? How about after the trial?
Jeez
Are you serious?? If I was a guy and my gf arranged to have a line of girls come queue outside waiting to have sex. with me? I’d be the most the grateful bf she’s ever had? False equivalency much? She could have packed up and left. She didn’t. She could have said no and screamed. She didn’t. They were all drunk kids. She’s an older woman who chose to leave her home after 11pm to go to a bar not because she was hungry and needed a late dinner. Just sayin. I’m not defending the behavior of these drunk dumb kids. I’m questioning the decision of a fully grown sober woman who made a decision to find a hookup after 11pm at a bar thinking she will meet Mr. Right now.
randomton
There’s a reason I didn’t say girls, I said your girlfriend invited much larger MEN to come have sex with you uninvited, and you’re drunk. How thankful are you now?
That’s what happened, so no reason to sugar coat it. She was inebriated from the club, she never knew or agreed to it beforehand, and felt forced by the large athletic men and circumstances.
That you weaseled out of the premise and then changed the facts of what really happened echos the article above. Victim blaming is repulsive, and I hope you take some time to self-reflect.
George T
To those that think CH is guilty no apology is enough. To those that think he’s innocent, nothing should stop him from playing hockey.
My take, people enjoy victim status either way.
John from canada
She got paid millions. Now go away!
Dave
Hart was found not guilty but NHL requires players with “highest level of moral integrity “. Asking for oral sex from a drunk naked girl at 3 am in a crowded hotel room so 8 of your teammates can watch is not that. He’s never publicly expressed any regret. CH shouldn’t be in NHL.
SMF
Thanks for giving victims a voice and for a clear explanation of the complexities of the situation, Ken.
buster
Gutsy article and I respect the young women who volunteered to share their experience with you and your readers.
I played hockey at a junior level and never had dreams of making the NHL but I love the game and still follow it.
One of the pervading realities of growing up playing hockey any level is the disgusting culture that is pervasive at arenas and among the largely male community of coaches, trainers, and lackeys that make the sport work from the ground up.
The whole culture is pervasively racist, sexist, and based on a ‘code’ of protecting bad actors and bad behaviour that is decades out of date (and should never have been allowed in the first place if the fathers of the game weren’t dirtbags themselves).
Hockey is hardly alone in this.
I am also grateful for the rise and popularity of women’s professional hockey. It’s a wonderful antidote to the gross, boorish, entitlement of people like CH and the folks that taught him how to be an abusive person.
Nikki
I appreciate you commenting this. I think it’s important to hear from people who were part of this hockey sphere and has seen first hand the culture surrounding the sport.
TS
Buster, thanks for your own truths, and sharing your experiences. Integrity DOES matter, even in the PRO world!!
TS
Thanks, Buster, for the inside look at male sports. In my young years in Vegas, there was a time or two when i found myself in sketchy situations, but i managed to talk my way out of them, thankfully
.Guess my “gift of gab” paid off then, and i’ve been overly careful since..my sons always complained that I was TOO careful and protective, but i parented from my OWN experiences, and i damn well know that shit happens when you let down your guard!
Note to ALL females: STAY SOBER!!
.
Richie-Rich
TS, I had a great Mom who told me that a single incident, one mistake in life could be a stain on my life and family name for the rest of my life. Carter Hart has to carry that stain for the rest of his life. So many have made these types of mistakes! Some pay a very high legal price while others get off easy. Hart will always have this over his head. I will root for our team, but I doubt we will see many #79 jerseys being worn by fans, especially women.
TS
RR, thanks to your Mom for giving you the moral compass to be a decent human being. It matters.
Jose
All of you are giving your opinions on a controversial topic without insulting and calling each other names for having opinions that differ from your own. It’s nice to hear.
I wish for Carter Hart to play well and have success because I am a fan of the Golden Knights. I don’t like or dislike the man because I don’t know him.
It appears to me that an 18-year-old kid used some poor judgement and has been punished for it. I say punished because he did not come out of this completely unscathed. He’s missed nearly 3 years, including the time during the trial and the additional suspension after he was given a not guilty verdict. Also, his reputation is forever tarnished. Deservedly so? Maybe?
Actual Hockey Fan
You’re a joke, Hockey Canada is a joke, and the kangaroo courts and (((media))) who propagate this sexual blackmail are jokes.
Gonz
Good on you Ken. This is the best article you’ve written. Didn’t expect you to ever really touch on this topic.
hdbiker7851
No one is condoning what happened or didn’t happen – this was a losing situation all the way around – there are all sorts of punishments – put yourselves in the shoes of all concerned and be honest with yourselves how you might feel and handle the situation. No one posting including Ken has any actual knowledge of exactly what happened especially given it was 7 years ago. It is interesting it was a female judge and not a male who rendered the decision- one can only imagine what the reaction would be with the same verdict. We have no idea how much E.M. received from the league and apparently was content to have the entire situation go away rather than being dragged thru the mud again. If anything, let’s hope lessons were learned all the way around going forward – nothing will change the past.
Emmanuel
I wonder why would VGK roll the dice on a mediocre talent with SERIOUS “off ice issues”?
I wonder if Hart would have been picked up if Pietrangelo was still playing, he seems to me as the one player that would not welcome Hart (its a guess of course).
I wonder how the older players like Stone & Hertl REALLY feel about this.
I wonder if the players have been coached on what to say about the situation, if they all reply with the same answer its a red flag.
I wonder if the team will deny access to any reporters that ask uncomfortable questions.
I wonder what will happen when he plays in Canada or say Philly?
The FO has declined since the 2025 trade deadline. They have made odd/sketchy /cynical decisions. Something feels off………
Kris
First lenher then Connolly in draft and now heart vegas is becoming raiders of nhl fits the mold going after people with shaky pasts and history of arrests that haven’t proven anything other then money and stardom get you out of things.
TS
Your comment reminds me of former UNLV Basketball coach Jerry Tarkanien,who recruited and coached the ” misfits”. The players no other team.would take chances on. And he took these misfits to the top, the ONLY Championship in UNLV history.
The VGK had their own ” misfits”, and also took them to the top. Vegas takes chances, rolls the dice, bets on.the underdogs— It’s the Vegas Way!!
GKG
Good point, Emmanuel. The real question is how hard our players will battle in front of CH—assuming he gets the start. If they don’t rally behind their own goalie, he’s going to face a barrage of shots, with no one stepping in to block for him. That would set the stage for a painfully one-sided loss, the kind that becomes a talking point not just in Vegas, but across the entire league.
But if our Knights rise to the occasion —as true professionals do—they’ll show CH some compassion, dig deep, and play their hearts out to welcome him back to the NHL with a win. And when that final whistle blows, all eyes will be on that post-game ritual, watching to see how the players will acknowledge their goalie. The world will be watching. Especially if Howden is in the lineup.
Emmanuel
Why Howden?
I mentioned Pietrangelo, Stone & Hertl cause theyre older, my guess less tolerance with age/teen kids.
PJT
Howden was part of the World Juniors Championship team with Carter Hart and the 4 other defendants. He was the one that initially introduced EM to McLeod who then left with EM back to the hotel and then texted his team mates. Howden did not participate in the sexual assault but did send out a text message to the team to agree on what happened should they be investigated. He was subsequently a prosecution witness but he he did not do a good job in the stand claiming a recent VGK game concussion affected his memory. In that respect, he did provide the defendants some cover but on the other hand they may not be too happy with him for being a witness to the prosecution. However, had he refused to testify, it would then seem he had something to hide. So it’s damned if you do and damned if you don’t. I personally think he did the right thing by agreeing to testify.
TS
Yes, it does seem off, Emm..the ” Boy’s Club” mentality is pervasive, demeaning to women everywhere. Is Entitlement a prerequisite or requirement to play men’s sports??
Or is it a SYMPTOM of the flawed psyches of Americans?
.
Larry
I’m really torn about whether to wade into this forum because quite frankly I don’t know enough about the situation to have an opinion on it.
None of us were there that night, nobody on either side of that equation that night may actually have been there mentally due to the presence of alcohol or possibly even drugs.
Perhaps 2 and 2 may not equal 4 that night, as we ultimately don’t know who was right or wrong and what the very sad situation was. There are no excuses for what transpired, the alleged victim and the alleged perpetrators are the ones that must face and live with the consequences of that night and whatever impacts moving forward.
The time for condemnation on his signing and any protests about it should have been expressed at that time, at the present time he is a Golden Knight and as such as fans, we want him to succeed and be our answer in goal, because we are fans, and as Americans we believe in second chances, all are entitled to have that chance to prove themselves!
Vgkfan
Hey Larry thanks for your thoughts on the matter, none of this stuff is easy for anyone but your right all we hope for is he can provide capable goaltending and help the team win starting tonight. We will see, well I won’t cause it’s on espn+ and I don’t get that
TM
Hart should have never been in that room and, once there, should have left. As a sports celebrity, he has since failed to express convincing contrition. Conversely, E.M. insisted she was drunk and taken advantage of, but after reviewing hotel footage, Justice Carroccia did not find that argument to be credible, and additional inconsistencies in her extensive testimony led to the acquittal. However, in all fairness, as long as the accused can refuse testimony, those in the role of victim will always be at a disadvantage.
Bottom line, from a legal standpoint, Hart has the right to play hockey, and fans who are offended by his presence should disengage. Clearly, the Vegas Knights are counting on minimal negative impact. Nevertheless, all these extremely well-paid professional sports personalities need to wise up and be responsible for their public image and duties to fans who pay hard-earned cash to see them play and pay their salaries.
USMC
I believe CH was the only one to testify. Please let me know if I’m wrong but he is the only one I could find.
JB
None of us were in that room. A judge didn’t believe the accusers version of events. A 19 year old kid made a mistake. Time to move on and support this guy, now on our team. Hope he starts tonight and has a good game!
Jason Jacobs
Ken, this is a long standing issue in hockey (puck-bunny abuse if you will), that needs to change. There are some really strong statements that these survivors make that I hope we all ponder upon, and then make the necessary changes. The question always comes to my mind (I have 3 daughters) – what if this was your daughter? Maybe if we all thought this way then better behavior and intolerance for any level of abuse or coercion would exist. As one who has only been able to stomach a 30,000 foot view, thank for sharing this insight.
Bruce
Should Carter Hart be able to play in the NHL? Ken? I did not read the 91 page verdict or talk to two sexual assault survivors. The only thing I know is that he was found not guilty. Should Carter Hart be allowed to play, Ken?
Ken Boehlke
This is the video I did from the day Hart was signed by the Golden Knights. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Y5sQaZRio4&t=2s
I am admittedly a bit more apprehensive about his actions as I’ve learned more about the trial, however I still absolutely believe he deserves the right to continue his career. I also still 100% believe the Golden Knights went against their stated mantras (“protect the unprotected”) in being the team that signed him and gave him the opportunity.
To answer your question…
Should Carter Hart be allowed to play, Ken? Yes
JB
What would be the legal grounds that would prevent him from playing! None!
Tim
The problem is with Not Guilty in this age of no law and order who knows. We all know the crimes were committed but lawyers have a way of twisting evidence and before the trail is over the girls involved will get the blame for egging the boys on.
Jeff
Well damn.. right after reading the article portion I was amazed how Ken was able to lie to himself worse than E.M. lied to the court.. but now after reading the COMMENTS — I’m going to have to check with TheAthletic to see if it’s morally acceptable or not for me to watch tonight’s VGK game..
Jonathan
This article leaves out facts of the trial that don’t support the narrative they are trying to create.
EM had a boyfriend during this whole thing, that’s a fact.
EM went out that night and was partying with a bunch of hockey players, that’s a fact.
EM admitted on the stand that she went home willingly with McLeod cheated on her boyfriend with him, that’s a fact.
Multiple sworn testimonies say that EM was on the floor naked, masturbating, and berating the five players for NOT having sex with her. When asked about this, her response was, “I don’t think I did that… but even if I did… it only shows how drunk i was and therefore unable to give consent”. That’s a fact.
The (female) judge called her testimony, “completely unreliable and at odds with video evidence”, that’s a fact.
If I get arrested for drunk driving, go to court, get a “not guilty” verdict… then I’m not guilty.
Getting a couple of victims of drunk driving accidents to write an article on how drunk driving affected them doesn’t change anything.
What a trash article!
PJT
Based on the teams reaction after the penalty shootout as they swarmed their newly minted NHL goalie in his first NHL game in 3 over years, it looks like Carter Hart is deservedly welcomed to the family of misfits. All you haters out there, good bye and good luck as you find another new NHL team to root for.
Mike
An excellent conversation to have no question. We’ve all done irresponsible actions in our lives, most of us anyways, I know I did when I was younger. My motto, those who live in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones. I am not going to judge him and I don’t want to be judged as well from others because no one really knows me just as I don’t really know him. He does not have to completely reveal everything about this incident to the world if he chooses not to apart from what he had to do legally. Some may not like that, that is your choice and if you no longer wish to be a fan of the team or the league as result fine, your choice. We have free will to make choices in this world, such is life.
Jonathan
This article leaves out facts of the trial that don’t support the narrative they are trying to create.
EM had a boyfriend during this whole thing, that’s a fact.
EM went out that night and was partying with a bunch of hockey players, that’s a fact.
EM admitted on the stand that she went home willingly with McLeod cheated on her boyfriend with him, that’s a fact.
Multiple sworn testimonies say that EM was on the floor naked, masturbating, and berating the five players for NOT having sex with her. When asked about this, her response was, “I don’t think I did that… but even if I did… it only shows how drunk i was and therefore unable to give consent”. That’s a fact.
The (female) judge called her testimony, “completely unreliable and at odds with video evidence”, that’s a fact.
If I get arrested for drunk driving, go to court, get a “not guilty” verdict… then I’m not guilty.
Getting a couple of victims of drunk driving accidents to write an article on how drunk driving affected them doesn’t change anything.
Ken Boehlke
The entire verdict is linked in the article.
Richie-Rich
I’ll weigh in on this. I was born right before the “free love and sexual revolution era”. I am not going to say that people before that were completely moral and respectful. Prior generations certainly have had their own share of this sort of sexual perversion, orgies, etc.. What is going on today and since the sexual revolution is completely on a different scale altogether. Violence and pornographic materials are mainstream acceptable. Oral and anal sex acts are actually taught and promoted in many public schools across the country. In my day (60s), there were about a handful of “girls” who everyone knew was “putting out”. Today the statistics are reversed. You can only find a handful of girls who haven’t been sullied. I think the entire situation is unacceptable. The outcome of the sexual revolution has been a dual edged sword. My own grandparents in Italy were not allowed to be left alone while out on a date, and absolutely no holding hands! Chaparone’s were the rule of the dating my daughter! After reading through all of this “crap”, there’s enough blame to go all around. The days of gentlemen and ladies appear to be something to mocked, a thing of the past. Instant gratification, and sex for pleasure alone is a recipe for social immorality. This entire affair makes my stomach turn. I wish Ken would just delete this entire thread. I don’t just look at the victim or the perpetrators of this sad and tragic incident. I look at our entire western sick immoral society, media and gaming, movies, print, porn, education, and communities disintegrating in the name of “progress”. How about a little RESPECT, and treating others the way you would like to be treated? Let’s try doing that each and every day.
Natalie
“Sworn testimonies”… yet Howden was almost perjured for giving inconsistent statements in the trial when compared to pretrial. You’re absolutely right that this girl had inconsistencies, but as did the men. You’re clearly one sided here. And you fail to mention that McLeod was caught in a lie on camera. I’m not saying the decision wasn’t correct. I’m just highlighting your bias here.
Darla
Thanks for doing this article. I appreciate the perspective.
James
I heavily appreciate the research done for this article. Thank you Ken for the educating report! Comments like “She should never have put herself into that situation in the first place” or “He’s probably remorseful, give him a chance” make me nauseous. “If it were your daughter?” should make you respond with you’d want to either murder the boys or put them behind bars. “If it were your son?” wouldn’t you want him behind bars to learn his lesson? You really would be okay with a rapist as a son? Just wait until his next case. This is where monsters start. He has not atoned for this at all. That girl has a team of ghosts following her everywhere she goes, keeping her from sleeping, preventing her from forming any kind of potentially healthy relationship in her life. While these boys get a stern look by people who happen to know what they did? This is absolutely disgusting. I’m so disappointed on this team. Now I know any continuing die hard fans are people I need out of my life. If you’re still on the wagon, enjoy supporting rapists. I hope the women in your life find peace outside of your home one day.
Dave from Toronto
The judge was clearly biased against the victim. The judge was new to the bench and had spent most of her career as an attorney prior to being a judge DEFENDING CRIMINALS. In other words, she had a predilection and an entire career for defending violent and dangerous man.
Next, repeatedly during the trial, she excluded evidence that would have been favorable for the prosecution, including statements from one hockey player who witnessed how hard she was being smacked.
Third, the biased judge excluded the statements that the hockey players gave to an internal investigation conducted by the NHL. Those statements contradicted other statements they made. If anyone had a credibility gap, it was the hockey players themselves.
Fourth, the biased judge completely ignored that the victim was drunk. Drunk people can’t give consent.
Fifth, the biased judge dismissed the jury because she knew the verdict was not going to go in the direction of the hockey players and she took over making the decision so she could give the decision she wanted all along, which was in favor of the players.
Sixth, picture this: one naked scared intoxicated surprised and confused 160 lb woman versus six or eight 200 lb athletes one with the golf club. Just picture it. What would you do in that situation if you were a woman?
Seventh, what kind of guy passes his girlfriend around to other guys to have sex with? What kind of guys take part in something like that?
Eight. Almost all the hockey players clammed up and refused to testify. Why? Because if they testified their previous statements and contradictions and lies would have been laid bare. The victim had to endure maybe four or five days of rigorous questioning by multiple attorneys. The players didn’t have to face any questioning at all. Is that a fair fight. Absolutely not.
Nine. The victim was consistent from the time of the event to the day after in the weeks and months afterwards that she didn’t consent to anyone except the first player. Everyone ignores that. She has the text message from right after.
Ten. The player started texting each other to try to get their stories straight when they realized that she may not have consented.
Do I think there’s blame all around, both on the female and all the players involved? Yes.
Do I think the players engaged in a cover-up to protect each other? Yes.
Do I think the trial was rigged in favor of the players? Yes.
Do I think the players treated the female with respect? No. They treated her like trash, like a piece of meat. Their behavior was disgusting.
Do I think the players are a fine example of athletes? No. Not one of them manned up and said what really happened. None of them owned up to what they did. None of them are good examples of manliness or what a man should be like. None of them are role models for teenage boys or other men.
Did any of the players take actual responsibility for their actions? No. Their behavior during the trial was abhorrent. They had smug looks on their faces. They and their attorneys laughed and ridiculed the victim. As a man, what I let my daughter date any of these goons, no.
Should Carter Hart play in the NHL? I don’t know. Would I know is that if I owned a team. I would not hire him. It reflects poorly on me as an owner and on the integrity of my team.
Can Carter Hart redeem himself? Absolutely. Everyone deserves the second chance. But it starts with a full acknowledgment first to oneself and then to others about what they did wrong. No excuses. No victim blaming. Just taking responsibility for your part. Actually, the second acknowledgment needs to go to the victim. The two of them need to have a private discussion. If it is an honest discussion, the end result would be a statement from the victim saying that she understands her role in the ordeal and that she forgives him for his role because he is truly repentant.
One can always dream. Unfortunately, for many of these hockey players, this probably wasn’t the first time they borderline raped females or treated them like trash. They’ve been treated like kings since they were kids probably with very few repercussions.
Let’s see what the future holds.
ulf
Recent activity by the Knights and the candor of the ESPN crew led me to review past articles on Hart as well as the civil case, where “EM” was paid off by Hockey Canada as a settlement instead of going to trial, where she would have won.
Thanks for this article Ken. Good reporting and an important voice to reflect on now.
Hart should never have been on this team
Awful situation
Umm the author is forgetting a major point: She got a major settlement from hockey canada. Don’t forget how her step dad contacted hockey Canada as well. Not saying that eliminates the morality of what happened but you aren’t telling the full picture. Absolutely the events are egregious and I see E.M.s side. But why was her testimony different vs when she got her huge payout? You’ve conveniently left out these key facts (that was even indicated in the verdict). Not saying hart is innocent. He should have never gone to that room or he should have left and done something. No dispute. But E.M.’s credibility unfortunately was destroyed. I also think it’s not her fault either (regarding the credibility.) She was put into a bad situation by her own family and the prosecution. The whole situation stinks if you ask me.
CrackerBarrell
lmfao holy shit just a bunch of literal rapist defenders in these comments. i knew the Knights were a dogshit excuse for a franchise owned by an evil oligarch, but holy hell their fans are just outright demonic troglodytes!
NotACultist
Keep your drinks covered in these comments. Damn, so most Vegas Golden Knights fans are just straight up defenders of gang-r*pists, huh? Mods deleting comments of people calling out this scum organization for running literal protection for a r*pist, by hiding him from the press & media. Probably the ONLY pro athlete I have EVER seen be allowed to just never be available to the media, without being fined or suspended for it. God forbid he have to answer a tough question! Poor lil monster. I thought he changed & wanted to make a difference? If that were true he’d donate his entire salary to funds for victims of SA, or maybe advocate for harsher sentences, or maybe do ANYTHING that isn’t just acting like nothing happened. This team is a stain on professional hockey. Also objective fact, INNOCENT PEOPLE DO NOT PAY ALLEGED VICTIMS INTO PERMANENT SILENCE, ONLY GUILTY PEOPLE DO THAT!