Praise Be To Foley, Vegas Golden Knights Hockey Website

NHL Competition Committee Recommends Six Rule Changes

(Photo Credit: Photographer Brandon Andreasen)

Every year the NHL changes a few rules. There a few steps to new rules being put in place with the first being a group of NHL players, coaches, GMs, and owners called the “Competition Committee” getting together to come up with recommendations that are then sent to the GM’s meetings for review.

That group recently met and they came up with six changes they recommend for the 2019-20 season. Here’s what they recommended and how I feel about each of the potential rule changes.

Helmets Off During Play – The Committee recommends work on a rule construct for implementation next season that would reasonably require a player to leave the ice in the event his helmet comes off during play.

It’s kind of surprising this rule hadn’t been put in place already. I’m not even a favor of the word “reasonably” being in this recommendation. Let’s just simplify it, no helmet, no hockey. If you lose your helmet, get the heck off the ice.

Expanded Video Review/Coach’s Challenge – The Committee recommends changes to the Coach’s Challenge and expanded video review, including as it relates to a Referee’s ability to review some of his own calls on the ice. Recommendations will be prepared for the League’s Board of Governors, General Managers and the NHLPA’s Executive Board.

This is fairly vague, so we’ll still have to wait and see what they end up going with for next year. I’ve made it fairly clear how I would like the see the review process changes, both here and on the latest Podcast. So we’ll skip this one, but at least we know some change is coming.

Goalies Unnecessarily Freezing Puck – The Committee recommends that the defensive team not be permitted a line change when a goalie freezes the puck on any shot from outside the center red line. The offensive team will have the choice of which end zone dot the face-off will take place.

Absolutely love this rule and hope it’s the beginning of more rules banning goalies from freezing the puck. This particular one is a simple change that won’t effect the game much at all, but it’s opening the door for more.

I’d like to see the rule go as far as, no freezing the puck unless the goalie is in the crease. I’d also like to see referees and linesmen be a little more proactive forcing goalies to put the puck back in play. If the goalie doesn’t oblige, use the NBA’s style of delay of game where there’s one warning before a penalty is called.

Face-off Procedure Changes/Line Changes – The Committee recommends: i) that following an icing, the offensive team will have the choice of which end zone dot the face-off will take place. ii) To begin a power-play, the offensive team will have the choice of which end-zone dot the face-off will take place. iii) That no line change be permitted for the defending team if, in the judgement of the Official, the actions of a skater of the defensive team caused the stoppage by unintentionally knocking the net off. The offensive team will have the choice of which end-zone dot the face-off will take place.

These are all fairly straight forward and there’s no reason they all weren’t in the rules already. With more and more players specializing in winning draws on a certain side, there’s definitely an advantage to be able to select which side the draw will be taken on.

Puck Out of Bounds – The Committee recommends that when the attacking team is responsible for the puck going out of play in the attacking zone, all face-offs will be conducted at one of the two face-off dots in the attacking zone.

I’m actually not a fan of this one. If the offensive team shoots the puck straight out of play or a tip goes straight out, previously the draw would take place outside of the zone, if this rule passes it’ll stay in the zone. It feels like we are letting poor play off the hook. Take a terrible shot, make a horrible tip, throw a disastrous pass, you should pay a price. It was a minimal price of moving the puck outside of the zone, but a price nonetheless.

Regular Season Tie-breakers – The Committee recommends adoption of a proposal that would modify existing regular season tie-breaking procedures and adding additional criteria.

For a minute there I got excited because I saw the word tie and thought “maybe they are actually changing the points system.” But, no. Instead, they’ll probably be adding something into tiebreak procedure which currently is only three deep.

Right now here’s how the tiebreakers work to decide who makes the NHL Playoffs.

  1. The greater number of games won, excluding games won in the Shootout. This figure is reflected in the ROW column.
  2. The greater number of points earned in games between the tied clubs. If two clubs are tied, and have not played an equal number of home games against each other, points earned in the first game played in the city that had the extra game shall not be included. If more than two clubs are tied, the higher percentage of available points earned in games among those clubs, and not including any “odd” games, shall be used to determine the standing.
  3. The greater differential between goals for and against for the entire regular season. NOTE: In standings a victory in a shootout counts as one goal for, while a shootout loss counts as one goal against.

The new rule will likely add a fourth or even fifth criteria that will probably never actually come into play. So, for the most part, who cares? But, when in doubt, add more tiebreakers, because nothing is worse than the dreaded coin flip.


Paul Stastny Keeping Up With Father’s Legacy


Vegas Golden Knights Top NHL In Jersey Sales


  1. sj Snarky

    Nhl rule #1= if it favors the pet Sharks, then it is ok with the league

  2. bill

    Couldn’t the rule of the puck being in the zone be used to make a change as if you “accidently” knock the puck out of play you get a draw in your zone and can get your top line on.

  3. sjSnarky

    the rules are still biased towards the defense. Case in point, you can hand pass in the defensive zone, but not in the offensive zone. (unless you wear teal, that is)

  4. THE hockey GOD

    i’d like to see
    1- a bigger ice surface, play is boring now, too congested
    2- bigger goalie crease, and elimination of stupid trapezoid
    3- officials placed on each side of blue line in elevated see through
    boxes with red light option to push trigger when play off sides, get
    rid of off side reviews and momentum changes it causes when a player
    scores and you have to wait. Whatever these new blue line officials
    call stands.
    4- standard bench doors inside the blue lines, no more bench doors
    inside the offensive or defensive zones, no that does not mean putting
    them opposite of where they are now at red line, that would create a traffic jam
    5- each team must designate a Captain and two assistant Captains. Only a C or A
    can talk to official on the ice already. Any other player, or another A that comes onto the ice when there is a C or A already on ice, babbling at official gets an immediate unsportsmen like penalty. If neither on ice only the C can come off the ice
    to talk to officials during stoppage in play. (like thorton did in game 7 when there was C and A already on ice)
    I hate the new video reviews, need to minimize them.

  5. the hockey GOD

    vegas doesn’t have talent or depth to acquire elite, top of the class, players. Patches and Stone are the best they can do, but the likes of O ‘ Reilly are beyond their ability right now.

    The St. Louis Blues have acquired Ryan O’Reilly from the Buffalo Sabres.

    The Sabres got the Blues’ first-round pick in 2019 (top 10 protected), a second-rounder in 2021, Tage Thompson, Vladimir Sobotka, and Patrik Berglund. That’s quite an impressive haul for a rebuilding Buffalo team. O’Reilly has five years remaining on his contract that comes with a cap hit of $7.5 million. He was owed a $7.5 million bonus today, so the Blues will pick up the tab on that one. The 27-year-old had 24 goals and 61 points in 81 games last season. He’s racked up at least 55 points in each of his last five seasons. Expect his fantasy value to increase a little bit now that he’s on a better team, but he’ll likely continue to produce between 20-25 goals and 55-60 points.

    • Mike StG

      Gee, it’s too bad Vegas doesn’t have elite talent like McDavid and Draisaitl – we could be the Oilers! Or Taylor Hall, so we could be New Jersey! Or McKinnon, so we could ask him to play 28 minutes a game in the playoffs. Guess the oddsmakers who have TBL at 6-1 to win next year’s SC and Vegas next at 7-1 are just a bunch of idiots. Lol! And, I wouldn’t trade places with Buffalo in a hundred years. Their problems are systemic management issues, not player related.

  6. Tommy Herda

    Changes to NHL rules
    If a coaches challenge is correct the team should be granted another challenge because it was the referees that made the mistake.

    • Skaters are still allowed to freeze the puck using skates and sticks against the boards?

      This doesn’t seem to get whistles any longer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén